12.4.11

Piccadilly

As a disclaimer, I've taken the Silent to Sound film studies class, so I'm familiar with silent films, and generally like them. But for some reason I found Piccadilly intensely boring. The problem, I think, was that I was comparing it all along to another film from the same year, Pandora's Box. Pandora's Box is a German silent film about a dancer whose uncontrollable sexiness leads to despair, death, and her own eventual murder by Jack the Ripper. Lulu, as played by Louise Brooks, is part free-wheeling innocent, part scheming seductress, and it's her performance that makes the film what it is. Interestingly in relation to Piccadilly, Brooks popularised the bubikopf - the short, sharp bob haircut Anna May Wong's hair imitates in this film.

Louise Brooks as Lulu in Pandora's Box.
What I like most about Pandora's Box is the unabashed joy Louise Brooks/Lulu has in her own seductive powers. She loves people, and she loves to be loved. The film is set in Berlin at a time when the city was known for its hedonistic, avant garde, and sexually open artistic sphere. The musical/film Cabaret romps through this world, showing its final days prior to the rise of fascism in Germany. German films of the Weimar era drew on a futuristic aesthetic, a kind of hyperactive art deco, and while Pandora's Box isn't as abstract in its design as films by directors such as Fritz Lang, it still has that grand, modern style. The fashion and hairstyles, as well as what is regarded as the first depiction of a lesbian in film, make Pandora's Box ahead of its time when compared to American films of the same era. Released about six months before Piccadilly (in Germany) I feel that Pandora's Box is doing a similar thing in a more interesting way.

Vic, Mabel and Shosho in Piccadilly.
 I suppose it depends what you see Piccadilly as attempting to do, but if the moral is one read along gendered lines (assuming there is some sort of moral, and ignoring the racial aspect) both films seem to have a message about women who are commodities (performers, in particular) attempting to turn their commodity status into a kind of purchasing power of their own. Lulu, Mabel and Shosho's lives go awry (or end) when they misinterpret their commodity value as power and try to wrangle themselves stable positions as the wives of the men who employ and exploit them, rather than settling for their appropriate partners; other employees. Mabel should go with Victor, who is the real attraction in their partnership. Shosho should stick with Jim, her equal in race and class. In Pandora's Box, Lulu toys with the son of her... the man she is the mistress of (you can't exactly say 'master', can you? But there isn't a name for it! You can be a concubine, but not a concubiner, a mistress, but not a master), before marrying the father. Lulu attains a bit of a coup here, stealing her man-she-is-the-mistress-of (who also backs the shows she dances in) back from his (wealthy, sophisticated) fiancee by throwing a screaming tantrum (see top two images above). After the wedding, her husband finds her with his son's head in her lap, and attacks her. In the ensuing tousle he is killed, and Lulu faces prison. From there it gets rather messy. The lesson for Lulu is that she has overplayed her hand in trying for the father rather than settling for the son, who is more her equal.

I would say Shosho is Lulu's parallel in Piccadilly, and while I don't know that Piccadilly could feasibly have been influenced by Pandora's Box the thematic similarities are notable, as are the physical similarities between Anna May Wong and Louise Brooks, in their hair and their small, slim body types. Next to the curvaceous and handsomely feathered and upholstered Mabel, Shosho looks tiny, and very young. Lulu and Shosho, young, slim, often near-naked, with their hair close about their heads, are indicative of a new type of femininity. The New Woman is androgynous, free spirited, alluring and flirtatious. The kind of slang recorded in this 'Flapper's dictionary' indicates something about the attitude of this type of young woman in the 1920's. To my mind, while Lulu still ends up murdered in an icy London garret, Pandora's Box seems to offer a more forward-looking view on this trend in its more thorough exploration of Lulu's character. Shosho is less sympathetic largely because we don't see enough of her. I found Piccadilly less interesting because I didn't care for any of the characters in the same way I cared about Lulu. Piccadilly's view on the New Woman seems particularly grim, with none of Lulu's joy.


8.4.11

Berlin: Symphony of a City and Man With a Movie Camera

I just went on an internet journey in researching this post which pretty much peaked when I found this quote: "The male lead, played by Ewan McGregor ("Trainspotting"), is a bisexual translator named Jerome who spends most of the film with his uncircumcised penis flapping in the wind." Sounds fairly promising, I think. The journey itself was fairly straightforward, it's from a Salon interview with director Peter Greenaway, and I've been trying to track down an interview I heard last year on ABC Classic FM in which he discussed the changing nature of film viewing. The interview isn't there any longer, but hopefully I won't completely mangle what he said in trying to remember it. 


I was reminded of this interview because in it he discussed the way he watches films. He said he hadn't been to the cinema in about ten years, and that he much prefers to watch films at home, where he can eat what he likes, talk, answer the phone, and stop, start and rewind at a whim. In other interviews, such as this recent one with The Guardian, he says artists should always be at the cutting edge of technology, and it's this technology that imparts more control over the text to both the creator and the spectator. This is obviously a modern way of viewing, turning the film into less of a cinematic experience and more of a personal commodity. To an extent, silent films have an element of this non-universality of experience in their music, which would necessarily be different everywhere the film was shown, and possibly in the projection rate. But this is still a communal experience, whereas the viewing style Greenaway talks about, and the style most of us were talking about regarding these films, is very much isolated and personalised. 


I noticed our discussions of Rutman and Vertov kept coming back to what role music or YouTube or silence played in individual understanding or appreciation of the films. Personally, I watched both of them with the Cinematic Orchestra soundtrack for Man With a Movie Camera. I already had the soundtrack and I didn't know when I watched Berlin that it and Vertov's film were almost identical in intention, style, and (crucially) length. I just stuck it on and marveled at my own ingenuity when the results were so excellent. It seemed less miraculous the next week when I watched Movie Camera and it was practically identical. 


This sense of control over the film by playing the music I wanted with it was undermined by a guilty feeling stemming from not watching it with its intended soundtrack. Until I actually tried watching it with the 'real' soundtrack, of course, and it was so didactic that I would rather have watched it with practically anything else. I've decided to watch silent movies with music that makes me feel more sympathetic to the film, rather than what might be contextually appropriate (although the question of trying to be sympathetic to the text and put the wishes of the creator first is fraught itself). So, for example, if I watch Metropolis I prefer this soundtrack by The New Pollutants, because it's brilliant, and modern in a way that suits the futuristic aesthetic of the film. 


Given that the films we're watching are concerned with and reflective of the modernity of their own times, it seems appropriate to use the technology available in watching them. It doesn't seem to me to be a question of whether or not this is how the films were supposed to be experienced, but I know there's an argument for the immersion of a communal experience of theatre viewing out there which might be convincing. 


And to demonstrate the wizardry of the internet, this quote from the Guardian interview about Greenaway's latest film Nightwatching links me neatly to the previous post: "Martin Freeman plays Rembrandt: oddly plausible and often nude". I've never seen a Greenaway film but they sound like the sort you watch with headphones on and one eye on the door.

31.3.11

Hello, CinMod




In (moderately) relevant things, this is the South Korean trailer for the BBC show Sherlock. Apparently whoever does the trailer editing for this particular station is a fanfic obsessed teenage girl. THE MUSIC! It's only mildly relevant to the subject, but I think it's hilarious, not to mention I'm obsessed with the show. It's fairly easy to mess with a show like this, particularly considering they let the homoerotic not-so-sub-text run pretty much rampant, with actors like Benedict Cumberbatch (who has the kind of intense gaze that burns holes in my tiny girl heart), and Martin Freeman, with his little quizzical wounded puppy face, not really helping. I'd be interested to know why it was cut together this way, whether the person who did it genuinely thought this was the main thrust of the show or if they were trying to appeal to a particular audience (the mad teenage fangirly one?). The kinds of shots they've used, much like the ones in the Law and Order video, are actually ones where they're all 'I deduce she's from Cornwall, she's been in London four hours and she's having multiple affairs' about a dead body, and aren't even remotely romantic. That 'look of disgust on account of having just seen a man's body washed up on the shore of the Thames' is easily transmuted into 'sorrowful look reflecting on difficult love for a man who's kind of a jerk' with a bit of romantic music and a dissolve. I think it's brilliant, and since the reason I found it was it was tweeted by Steven Moffat, who wrote the show, it's obviously something they were well aware of in making it.

2.12.10

Reading

I was going to leave this blog fallow until next semester, but since I've noticed people are actually still stopping by, if only to lurk, I figure I'll keep updating. I was going to write a long and pointless treatise about all the books I've read recently, but hey, no one cares. But I did read one, Wabi Sabi for Writers by Richard R. Powell, which might interest some people.

I'm not a writer, but I'm reading books about writing at the moment because... because. Anyway, this one was much more philosophy than actual writing advice, which could be summarised as 'show don't tell', and 'nature is nice'. So if you're looking for a practical manual for writing, this is not your book. In fact when I tried writing just after reading it I felt completely restricted. I wrote a couple of sentences which were pretty good, but I couldn't keep it up. But then, I'm an editor at heart and I find it difficult to write (and boy does it have some nice things to say about editors! Basically, I'm really selfless and humble and awesome. Rad). I really enjoyed reading it anyway, which must mean I'm getting old because I don't read non-fiction. It was just a nice thing to read, and the history of haiku was very interesting. I doubt I'll ever be concise enough for haiku but I felt by reading this book I started to understand it a bit.

Also, I have a Tumblr, which (as you might guess by the name) is mostly just a depository for bits gleaned from other people's gleanings. Which, you know, is the essence of Tumblr, really. I am about to post some pictures of a cat, though, so you know. Exciting things afoot. I spend so much time on the internet, having an actual live cat in my house is like a real life meme. Every time it does something I'm like, I could caption the hell out of that. I'm still trying to figure out how to get it to do surprised kitty. If it was bigger, I'd try throwing it. But I'm pretty sure the Cat Protection Society would have something to say about that. Something like, 'Hey! No throwing the cats!'

10.10.10

After Suspicion - Rita Felski

I don't know what I was doing the first time I read this essay but I sure as heck wasn't reflecting on it or considering how or why it might be meaningful. Probably I reflected on how nice and short it was.

On second approach I found it similar in some ways to the Smith reading, but much less daunting in terms of both the scope and nature of the text and the scope of its proposition. What Felski is asking is, instead of a database of historical and cultural contingencies affecting the ascription of value, for theory to recognise and question 'how and why particular texts matter to us.' Her proposed approach of 'neophenomenology' (and did I have fun reading the Wikipedia article on phenomenology OR WHAT) seems like an interesting way to allow the  personal meaning of a text to enter into critical discussion. By acknowledging 'how structures of feeling and interpretative registers are modulated across space and time' (sorry, I'm obsessed), we may be able to move beyond suspicion and mistrust of the text to 'develop more compelling and comprehensive accounts of why texts matter to us.'

This, I think, is interesting. I've often found with literary theory that I'm not given any good reason why a text is important or valuable, and that although I almost always find that, to me, it IS important and valuable, the hows and whys of that value are inconsequential compared to the post-colonial or feminist or cultural reading I am supposed to be subjecting it to. These readings, as Felski says, do yield satisfying results of their own, but I'm also interested in the reasons why I was so utterly engrossed in What Maisie Knew when I know others found it tedious.

The difficulty with this approach seems to me to be the relevance such a reading might have, and its possible scope. For whose benefit would these readings be made? Really, the Smith article stopped short of detailing her changing personal response to the sonnets throughout her life not because it would be too long, but because it would be too boring. I'm interested in why people I know liked or didn't like certain texts, but generally that's because I care about them as people, not because their personal responses are particularly illuminating. But perhaps this issue is not so much about the relevance of a reflective reading so much as the potential for such a reading to remain superficial and formulaic, or to regress to high school level analysis ('Imagery creates images in the responder's mind, which makes them interested.' 'Rhetorical questions make readers question their own ideas'). The basis of phenomenology seems to be the study of how objects are perceived to all consciousnesses, which, as we saw in the Smith reading, would be an impossible way to approach literature. I'd like to read more about, and perhaps an example of, the approach Felski is proposing.